Key 2025 Off-Year Elections in Virginia
Oct 27, 2025Byline: American Pulse Staff
---
Dustin Olson, lead pollster for American Pulse Research & Polling, joined Newsmax’s Todd Starnes Show to discuss key 2025 off-year elections in New York City, New Jersey, Virginia, and California. Olson broke down how these pivotal contests are shaping up—and why this year’s races are defying the usual trends.
Off-Year Elections: Breaking the Pattern
Olson began by explaining that 2025’s off-year elections are not following the familiar political pattern, where the party outside the White House typically performs better.
“Typically, in off-year elections, the party outside the White House performs better. You would expect in places like New York City and New Jersey and Virginia, all blue areas, that you would have the Democrats doing really well, but we aren't seeing that.”
New York City: Mamdani Leads, But Not Popular
Discussing the New York City mayoral race, Olson said that while Democratic nominee Zohran Mamdani remains the frontrunner, his support is far from enthusiastic.
“We have a majority of people talking about how they can stop the Democratic nominee. Now, Mamdani is likely going to win, but he’s not actually very popular.”
Olson noted that American Pulse polling from August indicated there were pathways to challenge Mamdani’s dominance, but that opportunity appears to have closed as candidates failed to target Mamdani's weakest points in their advertising.
Virginia: A Blue State Turning Purple
Olson also addressed the increasingly competitive environment in Virginia.
“Well, the state has definitely become more blue and maybe purple. But it is true. The House of Delegates has swung in something like three of the four last election cycles."
Olson also pointed to the recent Special Session that was called in Virginia, which removed many Republicans from the campaign trail, hinting that one of the intentions is to prevent Republican delegates in competitive races, as well as gubernatorial candidate Winsome Earle-Sears, who oversees the State Senate as Lt. Governor, from spending 100% of their time on the campaign trail.
"It's amazing to see what they're doing because they're also taking all the Republican delegates who are in competitive races temporarily off the field.”
California: Newsom’s Gerrymandering Gambit
Olson discussed how the Virginia Special Session on Redistricting was a desperate play to recreate some of the GOTV motivation that Governor Gavin Newsom’s controversial Proposition 50 gerrymandering effort is having in California.
“There seems to be some level of desperation we've seen in California with Prop 50. That's Gavin Newsom's gerrymandering initiative that started off not that strong, but now the yes side of that vote is over 50% and trending towards 60% which means that it's likely going to pass at this point.”
Olson argued that such moves reveal the defensive posture of Democrat leadership even in their most secure strongholds, as voter confidence continues to erode.
📊 For more polling insights, visit PollingClub.com
GET YOUR OWN RESEARCH ROADMAP, STRATEGY SESSION, & QUOTE
Ready to gain a competitive edge? Submit the form below to begin the process of commissioning your own political poll and get at no obligation the following:
- Complimentary Research Roadmap, outlining the strategic insights essential for your success and how we would survey to get them
- Strategy Session with a Top Strategist & Researcher, offering expert analysis and tailored advice to achieve your objectives
- Special Discount on Your First Survey if you choose to move forward
Get Your Own Research Roadmap & Strategy Session Now—because optimal strategy requires transformative insights.
Want To Know the Headlines Before They Happen?
Join Polling Club to:
- Get exclusive polling
- Suggest questions to be asked in our public polling
- Decide topics we tackle in our public polls
Polling Club polls are public polls for media and polling club members and are different from internal surveys commissioned by clients. Also, don't worry, your information will never be shared.
We hate SPAM. We will never sell your information, for any reason.